Indian roots, American priorities: Why ‘Samosa Caucus’ rarely speaks up for India

Washington : The grouping of six Indian-American lawmakers euphemistically called the ‘samosa caucus’ in the U.S. House of Representatives leaves neither a lingering savoury taste nor certainly a sweet one. It’s a cross between the two. On carefully removing the outer folds of the ‘samosa’, the potato mush emerges, which tastes anything but yum. The core ‘Indian origin’ of these six folks is just that. Neither palatable nor digestible for the Republic of India, but still, by no stretch of the imagination, an alien taste either. So, we settle for that.

We can dismiss the story of this ‘samosa caucus’ or our frustrations with them in these not very flattering culinary terms. But the samosa caucus matters in the larger scheme of Indo-American relations, if for nothing else but coming in handy on some rare occasion when they just might advance India’s concerns on pressing matters to a succession of semi-tone-deaf American administrations.

The Indian-American commercial and defence relationship is of no mean significance. The trade relationship, on current estimates, is worth $150 billion, with a future potential expanding to 500 billion dollars’ worth. The Indian-American diaspora sends a whopping $23 billion in remittances back home annually. And the cumulative defence trade and acquisition relationship between the two countries is valued at around $25 billion.

So, yes, the relationship matters. Any kind of help that closes the perception gap between the two countries matters. If every drop contributes to filling up the ocean, then so do the contributions, if any, of this grouping of six — Ami Bera, Ro Khanna, Pramila Jayapal, Suhas Subramanyam, Dr Amish Shah and Pia Dandiya.

Now, influence generation, or as the wit would argue, influence peddling in the top echelons of the American power structure, is peculiar and does not necessarily work only on a government-to-government basis, as in many other countries. Sure, the personal chemistry between the top leadership of two different countries helps. But so does a multi-layered influencing system that ticks away of its own volition. These include confabulations and positive impressions with the Western media — an attribute and expertise India simply does not possess. It also includes lobbying with senators and lawmakers on Capitol Hill by hiring private lobbying firms. And then there is the route of building bridges with Indian-origin lawmakers who, in turn, intervene with the American administration for the greater good of their country of origin.

That again is a road so far very little travelled by our foreign policy mandarins and policy wonks sitting smugly in New Delhi.

US lawmaker Ami Bera sits on the subcommittee guiding Indo-Pacific diplomacy and intelligence oversight. Ro Khanna co-chairs the Congressional Caucus on India and Indian Americans. He also sits on the Armed Forces and China Competition Committee. Pramila Jayapal is on the Judiciary Subcommittee that outlines Democratic policy on immigration and enforcement.

In their own way, some of these Indian-origin lawmakers are near or in the vortex of real power vis-à-vis these subcommittees.

Does it mean their hearts beat for India’s interests and Indian concerns? Not necessarily. The primary concern of these lawmakers is their own constituencies, and Indian government interests are secondary or perhaps of no concern at all. There is a broad banding of these six lawmakers. They are all Democrats and represent the progressive collectivism of the Democratic Party of the United States.

It means a rainbow spectrum of Indian-American lawmakers whose progressive report card ranges from moderation to American-style progressive radicalism, which means stringent adherence to socialist principles. It also means a rejection of in-your-face nationalism and religiosity. That is another reason most, if not all, these lawmakers are critical of so-called ‘Hindu nationalism’ back home and are adversely disposed towards the present Indian government. That, incidentally, is the difference between the new stars in the Democratic firmament, namely New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Michigan’s senator-elect Dr Abdul Sayed, and Indian lawmakers.

Both Mamdani and Abdul Sayed wear their religious identity on their sleeves and are proud of their Islamic heritage. Indian-American lawmakers shirk from loudly acknowledging their Hindu roots. They reluctantly bring their Hindu identity out of the closet on Diwali or on swearing-in day but prefer otherwise to espouse democratic socialist principles. It could be argued that the older generation of Indian lawmakers are still trying to ‘fit in’ with the American system and reject overt religiosity, trying to be even more secular, liberal and left-leaning than their American peers.

At the same time, we must be careful not to brand all of them with a broad DSA (Democratic Socialists of America) brush. DSA is cutting-edge socialism in intent, nature and ambition. Some of these lawmakers have other priorities. Both Pia Dandiya and Los Angeles mayor-elect Nitya Raman prioritise community welfare. Their concerns are affordability, the cost of living, affordable housing and clean streets. Not so much radical socialist agendas.

The big-ticket issues affecting the Indian government vis-à-vis America are still the preserve of Ro Khanna and Pramila Jayapal. In that regard, Ro Khanna is a strange fish, while Pramila Jayapal is still linear in her pronouncements. Ro Khanna is a critic of the Modi government and has supported street protests in India to bring about political change. He has, on several occasions, called out the Indian government on human rights issues. But the same man does not shy away from engaging with the Indian government and putting forward its concerns. He is the only Indian-American lawmaker who has criticised the Khalistani movement and the nefarious activities of Gurpatwant Singh Pannun operating from US soil. All other Indian-American lawmakers have maintained an uncomfortable silence on this issue.

Ro Khanna is also a strong advocate for the evolving Indo-US strategic, economic and defence relationship. These are important data points emerging from Ro Khanna’s internationalist repertoire and should be taken seriously, especially because the man is a self-proclaimed 2029 presidential hopeful. Ro Khanna has also taken a stand against the current wave of discrimination unleashed in some parts of America against the Indian-American community.

Pramila Jayapal has voiced similar concerns, but she is known more for her trenchant criticism of the Indian government on human rights issues than for any other issue.

Besides trade and tariff issues, there are other issues hanging fire between India and the United States. USCIRF (U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom), an adjunct of the State Department, has acquired a notorious reputation in India for bringing out biased religious freedom reports directed against India year after year. The infamous 2023 California caste discrimination bill — SB 403, piloted by one Aisha Wahab, could have had, and still has, the potential to adversely affect hiring and HR policies of Indian corporates in the United States.

Have Indian-origin US lawmakers spoken out against these kinds of legislative and policy initiatives that could be troubling for India? No, not really.

But that could change in the future. The new batch of Pia Dandiyas and Nitya Ramans, and even Zohran Mamdani, are focused on local issues, homelessness, transportation and affordability. But the India story is not entirely missing from their vision. It is up to our foreign policy mandarins to resurrect India-specific cold cases in the US from the back burner and bring them centre-forward to a flame and a sizzle. With a little bit of help from Indian-American lawmakers.