The Lok Sabha on December 8, 2023, expelled Trinamool Congress member Mahua Moitra over the “cash-for-query” allegation through a voice vote amid chaos.
Union Parliamentary Affairs Minister Pralhad Joshi moved the motion to expel Moitra as per the recommendation of Ethics Committee report, which found her guilty of sharing her credentials with others, and accepting gifts for favours from a businessman.
Though Trinamool Congress had strongly argued to allow Mahua Moitra to speak on the floor of the House, Joshi quoted precedence to object. Speaker Om Birla put the resolution to vote without allowing her to speak. Opposition members walked out of the House even as the vote was being conducted.
Earlier, Ethics Committee chairman Vinod Kumar Sonkar tabled the panel’s first report when the House re-convened at noon after an adjournment during the Question Hour. Trinamool Congress members and some from the Congress trooped in the Well of the House raising slogans demanding a copy of the report.
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee extended support to TMC leader Mahua Moira and expressed surprise that Moitra was not allowed to defend herself. She also thanked parties in INDIA alliance for backing Moitra. “Today I am really sad to see the attitude of BJP party. A 475-page report was submitted and after that they have half an hour time to go through it. I congratulate INDIA alliance that they supported her. Party fully supports Mahua Moitra. They didn’t allow Mahua to defend herself. It is betrayal of Constitutional rights. We have two third majority in Assembly does it mean we will expel someone,” said Banerjee.
“Mahua is a victim of circumstances and party is fully behind Mahua. I am shocked and it is sad day for Parliament. It is unacceptable and Mahua will win the battle. They will be defeated in next elections,” the TMC supremo added.
Trinamool Congress MP Kalyan Banerjee had said the party has written to Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla, urging him to give at least 48 hours to read the ethics panel report. However, the resolution was taken up for discussion after the House assembled after lunch. The Lok Sabha witnessed two adjournments on Friday over the report amid Opposition protests.
Amid uproar, BJP member Rajendra Agrawal, who was in the chair, adjourned the proceedings till 2 p.m. Businessman Darshan Hiranandani, who allegedly paid Moitra to raise questions in Parliament about the Adani Group, had claimed in a signed affidavit that Mahua Moitra targeted industrialist Gautam Adani to “malign and embarrass” Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
At a meeting on November 9, the Committee adopted its report recommending Moitra’s expulsion from the Lok Sabha over the “cash-for-query” allegation. Six members of the panel, including suspended Congress member Preneet Kaur, voted in favour of the report. Four members of the panel belonging to opposition parties submitted dissent notes.
The Opposition members termed the report a “fixed match” and said the complaint filed by BJP Lok Sabha member Nishikant Dubey, which the panel reviewed, was not supported by a “shred of evidence”. Moitra can be expelled only if the House votes in favour of the panel’s recommendation.
Trinamool Congress leader in Lok Sabha Sudip Bandyopadhyay described the Ethics Committee’s recommendation to expel party MP Mahua Moitra in a “cash-for-query” allegation as “political vendetta” and claimed that it was aimed at stopping her from raising issues against the Adani Group.
Bandyopadhyay said he had a one-on-one meeting with Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla, who informed him that the report would be tabled along with a resolution. He told the Speaker that Moitra should be given time to make her speech on the floor of the House to which Mr. Birla replied that half an hour would be given for discussion on the matter.
Bandyopadhyay asked why was the MP who alleged that Moitra was paid cash for asking questions not called to the Ethics Committee meeting. “The first meeting (of the ethics panel) ended in a short time and could not produce any result. Why was a second meeting not held? Why such a hurry?” he posed.
Bandyopadhyay also asked why was the report being tabled on a Friday, which is dedicated to Private Members’ Business. “It could have been introduced on Monday… Everywhere we find there is some motivation. We can say it is absolute political vendetta,” he said.
Bandyopadhyay claimed that the government was “unable to digest Ms. Moitra’s allegation against the Adani group. “They want her to be stopped.” “The whole country has seen how the first meeting started and ended. This projection of the outcome and result of the meeting cannot go to the extent that one Member of Parliament is expelled,” he added.
Lok Sabha ethics panel broke every rule in book, says Mahua Moitra
Trinamool Congress leader Mahua Moitra alleged that the Ethics Committee of the Lok Sabha “broke every rule in book” following her expulsion from the Lower House on December 8 after she was found guilty of sharing her credentials with others and accepting gifts from a businessman to extend favours.
Moitra speaking at the steps of the Parliament after the Opposition parties walk out flanked by senior Opposition leaders including Sonia Gandhi and Farooq Abdullah among others said, “I am 49 years old, I will fight you for the next 30-years inside and outside Parliament.
“In essence I have been found guilty of breaching code of ethics that does not exist,” said Moitra after her expulsion from Lok Sabha.
“This committee and this report has broken every rule in the book. In essence you are finding me guilty of breaching a code of ethics that does not exist. The committee is punishing me for practices that are routine, accepted and encouraged in the house. The findings are based solely on written testimony of two private citizens whose versions contradict each other in material terms, none of whom I was allowed to cross examine. One of the private citizens is my estranged partner who with malaise intention masqueraded as a common citizen in front of the committee,” she added.
Moitra equated her expulsion with hanging by a “kangaroo court” and alleged a parliamentary panel is being weaponised by the government to force the Opposition into submission. She further claimed that without any evidence of cash or gift, “ethics panel decided to hang me without getting to root of issue.”
“Entire case against me based on sharing of login details, but no rules govern this aspect,” said Moitra. Adopting the recommendation of the Ethics Committee in the ‘cash-for-query’ matter, the Lok Sabha expelled Moitra from the House.
