International IDEA released the ‘THE GLOBAL STATE OF DEMOCRACY 2024 : Strengthening the Legitimacy of Elections in a Time of Radical Uncertainty’ yesterday.
The executive summary of this report is given below :
In one way, 2024 is a banner year for democracy. Dubbed by some an election ‘super-cycle’ year, it will set a record for the most voters in a single year in human history (Sorkin 2024). This would be a triumph of democracy but for the fact that the quality of elections in many countries has declined significantly since the last time voters went to the polls. Around the world, the credibility of elections was worse in more than one fifth of the countries we cover (39 of 173) in 2023 (the most recent year for which we have complete data) than it had been five years before, in 2018. The way that people engage with electoral processes has also been changing over the past several decades: turnout has been going down while the incidence of protests and riots has been going up.
“Between mid-2020 and mid-2024, one in five elections was challenged in at least one legal proceeding, with voting and vote counting emerging as the most-litigated aspects of the electoral process.”
We now live in an era of radical uncertainty, in which multiple, compounding challenges threaten the patterns of stability and growth on which we have come to rely. Amid this pervasive uncertainty, elections are now regularly disputed. When political leaders make public statements disputing the credibility of an election or take the step of challenging an election in court, it sends an important signal to voters. In some cases, such signals convey legitimate concerns about an election; in others, they are cynical attempts to erode public faith in an opponent’s victory. Between mid-2020 and mid-2024, one in five elections was challenged in at least one legal proceeding, with voting and vote counting emerging as the most-litigated aspects of the electoral process. During the same period, one in five elections saw a losing presidential candidate or losing party in parliamentary elections publicly reject the outcome of the election, and opposition parties boycotted one in ten elections. These factors combine to challenge public confidence in political processes.
Democracy continued its recent decline in 2023, with notable challenges emerging with regard to Representation and Rights. Assessing each country’s various areas of improvement and deterioration, we find that, on balance, four in nine countries were worse off in 2023 than they had been in 2018, while only one in four had improved, continuing a negative trend that developed roughly a decade ago. Challenges to democracy are found in every part of the world and at every level of democratic performance. Already-repressive contexts have continued to get worse, as governments have taken ever greater steps to suppress dissent and limit the ability of the people to choose who will govern them. At the same time, we find declines in democratic performance in countries that have been among the world’s freest for decades.
Amid this broad context of decline, however, many elections have delivered on their inherent promise as a means of ensuring that the people have control over decision makers and decision making in government and as such remain a cornerstone of democracy despite the current challenges. Recent elections in Guatemala, India, Poland, Senegal and many other countries have allowed the voters to have an effective voice. If democracy is ‘a system in which parties lose elections’ (Przeworski 1991: 10), then democracy remains alive and well in diverse countries around the world.
“Amid this broad context of decline, however, many elections have delivered on their inherent promise as a means of ensuring that the people have control over decision makers.”
Taking the election super-cycle year as a call to action, this year’s report uses the data as a jumping-off point for solutions to the challenges that elections face in 2024. In particular, we focus on how court challenges and refusals to concede undermine public perceptions of electoral credibility. The report concludes with a set of policy recommendations targeted at improving public confidence in elections. Many of these recommendations call for increased attention to communication with voters and for the incorporation of data on public perceptions into election management plans.
Key findings
In an election super-cycle year in which approximately 3 billion people will go to the polls, one in three¹ will vote in countries where the quality of elections is significantly worse than it was five years ago.
Electoral outcomes are disputed relatively frequently. Between 2020 and 2024, in almost one in five elections a losing candidate or party rejected the electoral outcome. Elections are being decided by court appeals at almost the same rate.
The global rate of electoral participation has declined as elections have become increasingly disputed, with the global average for electoral turnout declining from 65.2 per cent to 55.5 per cent over the past 15 years.
Countries experiencing net declines in democratic performance far outnumber those with advances. About one in four countries is moving forward (on balance), while four out of every nine are worse off.
Declines have been most concentrated in Representation (Credible Elections and Effective Parliament) and Rights (Economic Equality, Freedom of Expression and Freedom of the Press).
In addition to declines in weaker contexts, democratically high-performing countries in all regions have suffered significant deterioration, especially in Europe and the Americas.
While substantial progress has been made in improving electoral administration, disputes about the credibility of elections deal mainly with irregularities at the point of voting and vote counting.
Despite the many threats to elections and the declines found in many countries, elections retain their promise as a mechanism for ensuring popular control over decision makers and decision making. Incumbent parties have lost presidential elections and parliamentary majorities in many highly watched elections in 2023 and 2024.
The Preface of report is written by Kevin Casas-Zamora, Secretary-General, International IDEA.
“Elections have been central to International IDEA’s mandate and activities ever since the Institute was founded in 1995. At the start of this year, as countries that together account for half of the world’s population prepared to go to the polls, we resolved to redouble our focus on the need to support electoral integrity. We are doing this by developing the capacity of election authorities and other partners to manage risk; by convening dialogues to exchange practices and innovations; by leveraging our voice through a global communications and advocacy campaign to protect elections; and, of course, by generating and disseminating knowledge about the trends we are seeing and the lessons to be drawn.
Hence, this report focuses on the challenges facing electoral authorities and systems. In particular, the 2024 Global State of Democracy report emphasizes how procedural and substantive pressures influence public perceptions of elections, and how those perceptions in turn shape democratic outcomes. This report thus builds upon the contributions of International IDEA’s Perceptions of Democracy Survey report, released earlier in 2024, by shifting the level of inquiry for democracy assessment out of the ivory tower and into the public square.
Our report outlines the mounting threats to the quality and robustness of elections, a pattern highlighted by a dramatic 10-point fall in average turnout over the past 15 years but reflected in different ways and to different degrees in every region of the world. And the report links this trend to another growing phenomenon in elections globally—the refusal of losers to concede. Between 2020 and 2024, in almost 20 per cent of elections, a losing candidate or party rejected the election outcome.
This relationship between electoral quality (both real and perceived) and a smooth transfer of power is a two-way street. On the one hand, rising pressures on elections from disinformation and polarization, among other variables, expand the space for defeated parties and candidates to spuriously deny or reject the results. On the other hand, when outcomes are contested with vigour and often with vitriol, it can further raise public doubts about the validity and even the value of democratic elections.
Yet, as this super-cycle year has reinforced, elections remain the single best opportunity to end democratic backsliding and turn the tide in democracy’s favour. As shown recently in places as diverse as Brazil, France, The Gambia, Guatemala, India, Poland and Zambia, elections retain a remarkable ability to surprise the experts and, in some cases, strengthen democracy in the face of adversity.
“As this super-cycle year has reinforced, elections remain the single best opportunity to end democratic backsliding and turn the tide in democracy’s favour.”
The success of democracy depends on many things, but it becomes utterly impossible if elections fail. And since democracy is an ideal that must be believed if it is to be true, a failure of perception is as serious as a failure of substance. To keep democracy alive, we must preserve public trust in electoral pathways to political change. That’s why this report, its findings and, above all, its recommendations are so timely and so vital.”
The Global State of Democracy 2024
Summary –https://cdn.sanity.io/files/2e5hi812/production-2024/13a9afade1064f322f18657e1e4ecd8461fbc666.pdf
THE GLOBAL STATE OF DEMOCRACY 2024 : for full text click below link –
